Issue #128

Read The Room

Buyers Don’t Think Like You Think They Think

Enterprise selling looks rational from the outside. There are decks, forecasts, financial models, decision gates and very serious people nodding at spreadsheets.

It feels like a world run by logic, but that's only half the story.

Attention rises and falls. People switch between careful evaluation and mental shortcuts depending on risk, fatigue, politics and exposure.

If you miss that shift, you explain when they want reassurance and reassure when they want proof.

And that is how perfectly good deals start wobbling.

Two Ways To Look At Everything

There are two processing modes at work in every enterprise deal narrative.

In “Active” mode, buyers weigh evidence, test assumptions, compare alternatives and examine downside risk.

This takes effort. It shows up when the decision is personally relevant and consequences are real.

In “Passive” mode, buyers conserve energy and rely on shortcuts like brand, precedent and internal policy.

What feels safe to defend in a steering committee when someone asks, “Why did you choose them?” This is how corporate professionals survive.

Enterprise Deals Are Always Moving

A sponsor might spend thirty minutes dissecting revenue impact, then open the next session with, “Who else in our sector uses you?”

Procurement may interrogate cost drivers and then retreat into, “This is not our standard template.” Same person, different cognitive state. No personality disorder required, but being procurement they probably have a few anyway.

The mistake sellers make is assuming deep evaluation is always switched on.

It is not.

Sometimes you are presenting Shakespeare to someone who just wants a road sign.

Practical Judgement

You need a way to diagnose the mode in real time. Here are the signs to look out for:

• Ownership - Is someone clearly accountable for the outcome?
• Consequence - Is there measurable upside or downside tied to the decision?
• Specificity - Are questions detailed and pointed, or broad and procedural?

Active Mode

Clear ownership, real consequence and sharp questioning signal evaluation mode.

In that state, bring structure, quantify impact and show trade-offs. Surface risks and mitigation properly and actively invite challenge.

Passive Mode

Diffuse ownership, abstract impact and policy language signal shortcut mode. In that state, reduce complexity and anchor to precedent.

Emphasise alignment with norms to make the decision feel defensible. Think less courtroom, more “this is how these deals usually work”.

Sequence Your Case

Early conversations are usually about safety. Establish credibility, category clarity and fit first.

Only when someone’s name is attached to the outcome, do you introduce commercial modelling and scenario analysis.

During negotiation, expect oscillation because people revert to shortcuts under pressure. Reinforce normality and precedent while guarding the numbers you agreed during evaluation periods.

If you ignore sequencing, you will either overwhelm or underwhelm. Both are surprisingly easy and can be devastating to your timeline.

Simple Test

In any meeting, pause and ask yourself:

1. Who owns the outcome?
2. What happens if this goes wrong?
3. How mentally available are they right now?

If ownership is vague, consequence unclear and energy low, simplify, reframe, reassure. Do not roll out another slide with a complicated waterfall chart that IT swears is basic.

If ownership is explicit, consequences measurable and questions specific, slow down. Show your workings and walk through assumptions. Treat it like a proper commercial discussion.

Manage Silence

Silence can mean thinking, but It can also mean disengagement.

If you respond to every quiet moment with more explanation, you come across as nervous.

Instead, test depth with a focused question that requires effort to answer, then listen:

• Specific responses mean evaluation is active.
• Generalities mean restore safety, reduce complexity.

Mistake to Avoid

Do not treat every stakeholder the same, processing mode is a function of exposure, not job title.

The operations lead examines delivery risk, finance looks at capital allocation, marketing at reputational exposure. The executive sponsor examines strategic alignment.

All of them will care about career risk, that much is true.

Tailor depth and framing to what each person stands to gain or lose. One universal pitch is lazy and won’t work.

Never equate volume with proof, more slides do not signal authority. Brevity, specificity and clarity are the true indicators of competence and respect.

Direction

Understanding these two modes will change how you show up. You’ll stop flooding meetings with analysis when buyers need reassurance. You’ll stop offering surface comfort when buyers want rigour.

You read the room, adjust your intention, and reduce friction seamlessly.

Enterprise selling rewards judgement over enthusiasm. Recognise the right mode and match your message.

Let the customer’s cognitive state dictate your behaviour instead of your slide deck.

If you loved this then let me know and tell a friend who doesn't work for the competition - they'll definitely buy you lunch in return.

Once you win, here's a guide to getting the maximum value from the customer, click here.

600 1st Ave, Ste 330 PMB 92768, Seattle, WA 98104-2246
​Unsubscribe · Preferences​